← All articlesInterface design

Standard or innovation in UI: why I usually choose familiar patterns

An unusual interface can make an impression in a presentation. In everyday work it often turns out to be dead weight. In the systems I build I usually choose familiar patterns and depart from them only when it genuinely improves ergonomics. Here is why.

Users already know dozens of systems

The users of my systems rarely work in just one tool. Every day they use many other systems that are similar to one another. They know where to look for the menu, how a table filter works, what the bin icon means and where the save button is.

That is a huge asset. An interface that behaves the way users expect needs no training. Every departure from this average behaviour, on the other hand, has to be learned, remembered and kept apart from the way other tools work.

Originality has a cost

Non-standard solutions can be colourful and interesting. But if they do not serve ergonomics, they are unnecessary cognitive load. Users have to think about how to operate the system instead of about their task. In a system used for several hours a day, that cost repeats with every action.

When it is worth departing from the standard

The standard is not dogma. I depart from it when the typical solution clearly does not fit the task, for example when an operator needs to take in the state of many devices at a glance and an ordinary table cannot do that. Then the new solution has a concrete reason and you can check whether it works better.

The question I ask about every such idea: will users complete their task faster and with fewer errors? If the answer is “I don’t know” or “it will look nicer”, I stick with the standard.

Consistency within the system

Consistency within one system is as important as consistency with other tools. The same element works the same way everywhere, buttons are in the same places and the vocabulary does not change. This way users learn each new module faster than the previous one.

Let’s talk about your project

Tell us briefly what you want to build or fix.